Monterey, IN 46960 8995 S US Highway 35

8995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 18995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 28995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 3
25 more
8995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 48995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 58995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 68995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 78995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 88995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 98995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 108995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 118995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 128995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 138995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 148995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 158995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 168995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 178995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 188995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 198995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 208995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 218995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 228995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 238995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 248995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 258995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 268995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 278995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 288995 S US Highway 35 Monterey, IN - Image 29
Presented By: Kyle Pugh with Century 21 Scheetz - Carmel; cell: 463-224-2992
  • MLS# 202617625
  • 05/08/2026
  • Get pre-approved
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Baths • 3
  • SQFT • 3,132

Home Details

Jk Deli Turnkey Gas Station & Popular Polish Deli in Monterey, Indiana Prime opportunity on US 35 between Winamac and Bass Lake! Jk Deli is a well-established, high-traffic gas station and authentic Polish deli located right down the road from a major camping site and one of the most popular paintball courses in Indiana. This unbeatable location serves local residents, campers, paintball enthusiasts, and daily travelers year-round. Business Highlights: 3 gas pumps + 1 kerosene pump + diesel with steady daily volume Fully stocked deli and convenience store with all inventory included Complete kitchen setup and accessories ready for fresh Polish specialties Licenses in place for alcohol, tobacco, lottery, and more Additional income from a small home in the back perfect for owner-occupant or rental income Located in a high-visibility spot with strong daily traffic, this is a rare turnkey business with loyal customers, multiple revenue streams, and excellent growth potential from nearby recreational traffic. Ideal for an owner-operator or investor looking for a profitable roadside business in a fantastic area.
Presented By: Kyle Pugh with Century 21 Scheetz - Carmel; cell: 463-224-2992

Interior Features for 8995 S US Highway 35

Other Interior Features

Basement Y/NNo
Burglar Alarm Y/NNo
Interior Height10'-12'
Smoke/Fire Alarm Y/NNo
Water Heater Y/NYes
FIRE PROTECTIONTownship
Equipment Y/NYes
Basement/FoundationSlab
FlooringConcrete, Laminate, Other
WallsDrywall

General for 8995 S US Highway 35

# of Buildings2
Age85
Agent First NameKyle
Agent Last NamePugh
Annual Taxes2131
AreaStarke County
Associated Document Count
Auction Y/NNo
Bathrooms3
Ceiling Height10'-12'
CityMonterey
ClassCOMMERCIAL
CoolingCentral Air, Window, Multiple Cooling Units
DOM110
FIPS Code18149
HeatingGas, Space, Wall Heater
Legal DescriptionPt S 1/2 Se S35 T32 R2 .69a.
New ConstructionNo
ParkingYes
ParkingGravel, Lot, Paved, Private, Unpaved
REONo
RoofMetal, Dimensional Shingles
SewerSeptic
Special FeaturesHandicap Access, Living Space, Office Space, Public Restrooms, Other, Refrigeration/Freezer
StatusActive
StatusActive
Status Detail0
Stories Count1
SubdivisionNone
Tax Year2025
TownshipCalifornia
TypeRetail
Virtual TourClick here
Year Built1941

Exterior for 8995 S US Highway 35

Approx. Lot Size Acres0.7
Construction Type 1wood frame
ExteriorBlock, Metal, Wood
Ingress/EgressConcrete
Lot Dimensions312x121
Lot Size Area30492
Parking Typestreet and concrete lot
Road AccessState
Security Light Y/NYes
Sprinkler System Y/NNo
Water Softener Y/NNo
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Linda Jaroszewski

Broker
Price $800,000
MLS#202617625
List Date 05/08/2026
Property Type Commercial
Phone
Get pre-approved
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 8995 S US Highway 35