St. John, IN 46373 9857 Olcott Avenue

9857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 19857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 29857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 3
73 more
9857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 49857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 59857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 69857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 79857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 89857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 99857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 109857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 119857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 129857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 139857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 149857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 159857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 169857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 179857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 189857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 199857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 209857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 219857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 229857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 239857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 249857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 259857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 269857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 279857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 289857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 299857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 309857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 319857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 329857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 339857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 349857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 359857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 369857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 379857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 389857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 399857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 409857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 419857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 429857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 439857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 449857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 459857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 469857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 479857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 489857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 499857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 509857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 519857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 529857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 539857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 549857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 559857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 569857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 579857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 589857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 599857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 609857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 619857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 629857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 639857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 649857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 659857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 669857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 679857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 689857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 699857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 709857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 719857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 729857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 739857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 749857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 759857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 769857 Olcott Avenue St. John, IN - Image 77
Presented By: Amy Izzo with eXp Realty, LLC - (888) 611-3912;
  • MLS# 828770
  • 10/01/2025
  • Get pre-approved
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 3
  • Full/Half Baths • 1 / 2
  • SQFT • 2,049
  • Garage • 2

Home Details

This stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath quad-level home offers over 3,100 sq ft of beautifully finished space, professionallandscaping, and curb appeal highlighted by a charming covered front porch. Step into a spacious foyer that welcomesyou to a thoughtfully designed layout. The main level features a sunken living room with vaulted ceilings, exposed woodbeams, and abundant natural light. The adjoining dining room is perfectly centered between the living room and kitchen,creating an ideal flow for gatherings. The kitchen, fully gutted and remodeled in 2011, boasts custom cabinetry, granitecountertops, tiled backsplash, bamboo flooring, and stainless steel appliances--all included. The lower level Great Room is the true heart of the home, showcasing a striking floor-to-ceiling brick fireplace with a gasstarter and floating shelves on each side. Sliding doors extend the living space to a screened porch and deck, overlookinga serene, professionally landscaped, park-like backyard with mature apple trees and a storage shed. This level alsofeatures a convenient half bath, laundry room, and access to both the garage and basement. The partially finished basement includes a versatile office, craft, or playroom, along with plenty of storage in the unfinishedspace. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite offers double closets, dual sinks, and a private shower area. The guest bath isbeautifully updated with a new shower (2022) and toilet (2020). Extra features include a 2.5-car garage with a solid cedar door, washer/dryer, window treatments, and reverse osmosissystem--all staying. Peace of mind comes with major updates: furnace with humidifier and thermostat (2024), A/C (2020),sump pump with battery backup (2023), and newer appliances. Neighborhood amenities include walking trails, a fishing pond, and nearby parks, all just minutes from shopping, dining, and top-rated schools.
Presented By: Amy Izzo with eXp Realty, LLC - (888) 611-3912;

Interior Features for 9857 Olcott Avenue

Bedrooms

Total Bedrooms3

Bathrooms

3/4 Baths0
Half Baths2
Total Baths3

Other Interior Features

LivingAreaSourceAssessor
Above Grade Finished Area1202
Fireplace FeaturesGas, Lower Level, Wood Burning, Great Room
Fireplace Y/NYes
Interior AmenitiesCeiling Fan(s), Vaulted Ceiling(s), Other, Granite Counters, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Double Vanity
Laundry FeaturesGas Dryer Hookup, Washer Hookup, Sink, Main Level, Laundry Room
Total Fireplaces1
Window FeaturesBlinds, Garden Window(s), Bay Window(s)

Other Rooms

Room TypeBedroom 2, Primary Bedroom, Office, Living Room, Laundry, Kitchen, Great Room, Dining Room, Bedroom 3

General for 9857 Olcott Avenue

AppliancesDryer, Washer, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Refrigerator, Other, Microwave, Gas Range, Dishwasher
CitySt. John
CountyLake
Directions41 S to 93rd W to Olcott
ElectricCircuit Breakers
Elementary SchoolGeorge Bibich Elementary School
Full Baths1
Garage Spaces2.5
Garage Y/NYes
HOANo
HeatingCentral, Other, Natural Gas, Forced Air
High SchoolLake Central High School
High School DistrictLake Central
Legal DescriptionHOMESTEAD ACRES 1ST ADD. LOT 28
LevelsQuad-Level
Listing TermsCash, VA Loan, FHA, Conventional
Lot Size Square Feet19994
Middle/Junior High SchoolGrimmer Middle School
New ConstructionNo
Patio/Porch FeaturesCovered, Screened, Other, Enclosed, Deck
Pool FeaturesNone
Property Attached Y/NNo
Property SubtypeSingle Family Residence
Property TypeResidential
Security FeaturesCarbon Monoxide Detector(s), Smoke Detector(s)
SewerPublic Sewer
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive - First Right Contingency
Subdivision NameHomestead Acres 1st Add
Tax Annual Amount3124
Tax Assessed Value345900
Tax Year2023
Total Rooms10
TownshipSt. John
UtilitiesElectricity Connected, Water Connected, Natural Gas Connected
ViewNeighborhood
Year Built1976
Zoning Descriptionresidential

Exterior for 9857 Olcott Avenue

Exterior AmenitiesNone, Rain Gutters, Other
Lot FeaturesBack Yard, Landscaped, Front Yard
Lot Size Acres0.459
Lot Size SourceAssessor
Parking FeaturesAttached, On Street, Garage Faces Front, Driveway, Concrete, Garage Door Opener
Water SourcePublic
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

Middle School Grimmer Middle School
High School Lake Central High School
Elementary School George Bibich Elementary School

Maleah Matthys

Price $399,999
MLS#828770
List Date 10/01/2025
Property Type Single Family
Get pre-approved
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 9857 Olcott Avenue